Skip Navigation

Best Pizzeria in Sussex

Visit us today to get our weekly special!

View Pizza Menu

Italian Specialty Dishes

Authentic Italian pasta and subs

View Dinner & Subs Menu

Event Catering

Your wedding or other event caterer

View Catering Menu

Lorenzo's of Sussex

Pizzeria & Restaurant
67 Main Street
Sussex, NJ 07461

973-875-5055
Get Directions

Hours

Mon - Thu11:00 am - 10:00 pm
Fri - Sat11:00 am - 10:30 pm
Sunday11:00 am - 9:30 pm

Lorenzo's Pizza

History of Lorenzo's Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant

In 1972, Mr. Lorenzo Maltese opened Lorenzo’s Pizzeria on Main St in Sussex, NJ. David Case began working there as a teenager in 1993. When “Mr. Lorenzo,” as everyone called him, retired in 2010, David and his wife Laurie purchased the business and retained the name that everyone had come to know. 


Many of Lorenzo’s Pizza recipes have not changed since the doors first opened, though David and Laurie have expanded the menu quite a bit. 


When you walk into Lorenzo’s, you will notice a family-friendly atmosphere, a staff comprised of many of David and Laurie’s family members—many of whom have been with the business for a long time, and everyone will know your name. 

Pizza Place & Italian Specialities in Sussex, NJ

Lorenzo’s Pizzeria has several signature dishes. The lasagna is based on an original recipe from 1972. James the Pizza Man learned how to make pizza from Mr. Lorenzo himself; and David’s meatballs and cheese steaks are a big hit. Their belief is that you start with great ingredients: fresh produce, local meats, and freshly shredded cheese.


Lorenzo’s philosophy is to connect with their community. They sponsor several local teams, donate to tricky trays, and once a month they donate 10% of their profits to a local nonprofit organization. 


Come visit Lorenzo's Pizzeria in Sussex, NJ and have friends for life. Before you come, be sure to check out our pizza, dinner and subs, and catering menus. Like Lorenzo's on Facebook to keep up on our latest news and events.

Pizza

Lorenzo's Pizzeria offers authentic styles of pizza each unique in its blend of crust, cheeses and sauce. Add a variety of toppings when ordering any pizza style to customize your pizza to your taste.

View Pizza Menu

Dinner & Subs

We invite you to a true Italian dining experience with authentic Italian pasta and sub sandwiches. Try our signature Italian dishes like spaghetti, homemade lasagna and meatballs. 

View Dinner & Subs Menu

Catering

From custom trays and buffet style catering, Lorenzo's Pizzeria offers dishes for any event from weddings to meetings. If it's not on our event catering menu, we can do custom menus as well.

View Catering Menu

Contact Info

Lorenzo's of Sussex
Pizzeria & Restaurant
67 Main Street
Sussex, NJ 07461


973-875-5055

Follow Us On Facebook

Copyright © 2021 · Powered by ThriveHive